16-year-old James lives in her sister's shadow and strives to prove her worth by nabbing the lone varsity soccer spot. When her rival, Natalie, gets it instead, they form a pact that Natalie will (secretly) personally train her as long as James stays focused. Too bad James' crush from freshman year is *finally* crushing back and threatening that pact.

17-year-old Riley is a romantic with an anonymous matchmaking account who loves controlling things and dreams of being a director. Her crush ghosted her, but when Riley sees his name on the cast list for 'Emma', she thinks this is her second chance. Things spin out of her control when she tries to rewrite her love story while gripping tight to her director role and orchestrating matches in person. She needs to learn to let go before she loses everything.